Medicare Funding for Gender-Related Surgery: Natural Histories and Models of Care:  Response prepared for MSAC’s consideration of Application 1754

•

Genspect Australia has prepared a response to the Medical Services Advisory Committee’s (MSAC) assessment of Application 1754, which seeks Medicare funding for gender-related surgical procedures for adults.

Our response addresses the assessment reports on natural history and models of care, MSAC’s consultation questions, and additional clinical evidence.

Our Executive Summary is reproduced below, with the full response available to download.

Executive Summary

Genspect Australia opposes public funding for these surgeries. The case for listing assumes that those who seek them have a stable and intrinsic gender incongruence, and that surgery relieves the distress associated with it, and does not make that distress, or the conditions that accompany it, worse. Nothing in the Natural History and Models of Care assessments, or in the other published materials, establishes either assumption. The Natural History assessment treats the course observed under affirmation as the natural history of the condition, and the Models of Care assessment describes only affirming pathways. Yet affirmation may itself change that course, and close off others.

Diagnosis offers no safeguard. It rests on the person’s own account, and cannot distinguish distress arising from gender incongruence from distress with other sources, or those whose distress will persist from those in whom it will resolve. It is also increasingly not required in practice. Nor can robust evidence be gathered under current models of care, which offer one pathway and rarely follow those who depart from it, including people who stop treatment, disengage from services or detransition. Low recorded rates of regret and detransition therefore cannot be relied on as reassurance.

Publicly funding surgery for distress that may have other sources raises a question for a public health system: whether it should meet a need that its own models of care may have helped to create. Funding would also establish surgery more firmly as the expected response to that distress, and so may itself further alter the natural history of the condition.

Part B responds to MSAC’s questions on multidisciplinary assessment, team membership, surgical exemplars and post-surgical management, without prejudice to our position that listing should not be supported. Those questions cannot be answered satisfactorily without independent, evidence-based national standards for adult gender services, covering both hormone treatment and surgery, which existing guidance cannot supply. Optional multidisciplinary review and assessment would leave current practice largely unchanged, in which assessment rests with the treating practitioner and those most in need of assessment are least likely to seek it. Documented failures in Australian services show that a multidisciplinary label is not itself a safeguard.

Economic evaluation is premature: outcome data are short-term, the proposed exemplars may normalise escalating surgery, and the costs of complications could fall outside the proposed items. Post-surgical management should include long-term follow-up and support for people who come to regret surgery.

Part C draws MSAC’s attention to developments since our February 2025 submission. Recent large-scale studies using clinical records found continuing or increased psychiatric need after surgery or medical transition, and neither shows that these treatments improve mental health. Overseas, claims by people treated as minors and as adults have succeeded at trial or been settled, raising the same questions of assessment as this response.

WPATH’s standards have also been found deficient on independent appraisal, and WPATH itself, defending a US lawsuit, has described its standards as non-binding and its claims about the necessity, safety and effectiveness of treatment for children as opinion. Professional bodies have raised concerns that Australian conversion practices laws constrain exploratory care. While the alternatives remain constrained and unstudied, the comparative safety and effectiveness of surgery cannot be established.

We recommend that MSAC

  • not support public funding of the proposed surgeries,
  • irrespective of its decision, advise the Minister that an independent authority, such as the Medical Board of Australia together with other National Boards, should establish national standards for adult gender services, developed in accordance with NHMRC standards and covering both hormone treatment and surgery.